The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (2024)

Table of Contents
Unique Choices for an Engagement Ring Diamond Alternative Engagement Rings Moissanite Engagement Ring Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring White Sapphire Engagement Ring Colored Gemstone Engagement Rings Bezel Set London Blue Topaz Ring Citrine Engagement Ring Aquamarine Sterling Silver Engagement Ring Opal Engagement Rings Opal Art Deco Ring Oval Moonstone Engagement Ring Antique Opal Engagement Ring Rose Gold Halo Unique Engagement Ring Settings Oval Hal Engagement Ring Labradorite Marquise Engagement Ring Emerald Cut East West Engagement Ring Rose-Colored Stone Engagement Rings Blush Morganite Rose Gold Engagement Ring Rose Gold + Diamond Engagement Ring Blush Morganite Engagement Ring Ethically Sourced Engagement Rings Gold Bezel Engagement Ring Sapphire Engagement Ring Solitaire Engagment Ring Fancy Shape Engagement Rings Hexagon Faceted Rainbow Moonstone Ring Kite Shape Moss Agate Engagement Ring Marquise Moissanite Halo Engagement Ring Fully Custom Engagement Rings Custom branch band engagement ring Fully Custom Engagement Ring White diamond engagement ring James Allen Multiple Stone Engagement Rings Pear-shaped Moissanite 3 Stone Engagement Ring Custom 3 Stone Vertical Ring Three Stone Oval Sapphire Ring with Halo Dainty Cluster Engagement Rings Cluster Diamond Rose Gold Ring Vintage British Cluster Ring Rainbow Stone Engagement Rings Mystic Topaz Engagement Ring Rainbow Moonstone Engagement Ring Raw Stone Engagement Rings Rustic diamond slice ring Natural turquoise engagement ring Raw opal engagement ring Dark Stone Engagement Rings Black Diamond Hexagon Ring Black Onyx Pear Engagement Ring Oval Black Sapphire Engagement Ring Bezel Setting Engagement Rings Sunstone in bezel setting Bezel set sunstone ring Yellow gold bezel set engagement ring Vintage Engagement Rings Art deco ring Asscher ring Moissanite Oval Vintage Engagement Ring Flower Setting Engagement Ring Sunflower Black Diamond Engagement Ring Flower Morganite Engagement Ring Citrine Flower Engagement Ring Starburst Engagement Ring Settings Moissanite cluster engagement ring Round Simulated Diamond Starburst engagement ring Morganite cluster engagement ring Celebrity-Inspired Engagement Rings Emerald Ring with Sidestones Sapphire vintage style engagement ring Crown Halo Engagement Bands Antique style opal engagement ring Timeless emerald engagement ring with matching crown halo Rosecut Green Sapphire engagement ring with crown Unique Additions to make an Engagement Ring Extra Special Custom-Engraving Engraved engagement ring Engagement Ring with Signature Ruby Infuse a hidden meaning Mint Sapphire Engagement Ring Inspiration for Unique Engagement Rings 📌 Pin This! 📌 FAQs References

You’ve found a one-of-a-kind love that you want to spend the rest of your life with, so why not give your partner a one-of-a-kind, unique engagement ring to pop the big question?

Unique Choices for an Engagement Ring

When you find your one true love, you want to give them an engagement ring that is just as unique and original as they are. If you’re on the hunt for a truly unique engagement ring for your future fiancée, check out this list of customizations, creative additions, and thoughtful touches that can make your engagement ring more unique.

How do you ensure that the ring you choose for your future spouse is truly unique? Try some of these tips!

Diamond Alternative Engagement Rings

If a diamond is out of your budget, choosing moissanite or cubic zirconia instead can give you more bang for your buck.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (1)

Moissanite Engagement Ring

from ShyGemsStudio on Etsy

Solitaire rings are by far one of the most popular engagement ring styles, but you can customize them with a diamond alternative.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (2)

Herkimer Diamond Engagement Ring

from greengem on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (3)

White Sapphire Engagement Ring

from LoveRingsDesign on Etsy

Colored Gemstone Engagement Rings

If your partner is into color, consider a gemstone engagement ring to give her something truly unique and stunning. Incorporating colored alternative gemstones into an engagement ring creates a truly custom design.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (4)

Bezel Set London Blue Topaz Ring

from CaratDesignGifts on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (5)

Citrine Engagement Ring

by willwork on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (6)

Aquamarine Sterling Silver Engagement Ring

by Jadorelli on Etsy

Opal Engagement Rings

If you’re looking for something special, choose a multicolored stone for your engagement ring: opals are a big hit with millennials this year.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (7)

Opal Art Deco Ring

from HKFineJewelry on Etsy

We love halo rings, and this Opal Art Deco Engagement Ring is a very special look!

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (8)

Oval Moonstone Engagement Ring

from MollyjewelryUS on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (9)

Antique Opal Engagement Ring Rose Gold Halo

from LoveRingsDesign on Etsy

Unique Engagement Ring Settings

Instead of the standard North-South stone placement, consider choosing a ring with an oblong stone oriented East-West for a unique look.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (10)

Oval Hal Engagement Ring

from PescaraJewelry on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (11)

Labradorite Marquise Engagement Ring

by AnemoneUnique on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (12)

Emerald Cut East West Engagement Ring

from ZhedoraArgento on Etsy

Rose-Colored Stone Engagement Rings

Instead of traditional yellow gold, opt for a rose-gold setting for your engagement ring for something romantic and unique.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (13)

Blush Morganite Rose Gold Engagement Ring

by ShyGemsStudio on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (14)

Rose Gold + Diamond Engagement Ring

from DiorahJewellery on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (15)

Blush Morganite Engagement Ring

from AUSGEMSCo on Etsy

Ethically Sourced Engagement Rings

When shopping for a unique engagement ring, seek out ethical suppliers and makers to create an extra special and benevolent bauble.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (16)

Gold Bezel Engagement Ring

from ShaktiEllenwood on Etsy

This unique ring is made of fairtrade gold and features a salt and pepper diamond. Bezel settings are a unique choice for an engagement ring.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (17)

Sapphire Engagement Ring

from EnveroJewelry on Etsy

This ethical ring features a Bi-color Queensland sapphire

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (18)

Solitaire Engagment Ring

from AideMemoire on Etsy

This ethical ring features a Bi-color Queensland sapphire.

Fancy Shape Engagement Rings

Instead of a traditional round or square center stone, go for a fancy shape for your ring’s focal point. Check out these unusual diamond shapes and gemstone options for engagement rings:

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (19)

Hexagon Faceted Rainbow Moonstone Ring

by SimplyCharmed21 from Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (20)

Kite Shape Moss Agate Engagement Ring

by AuroraDesigner on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (21)

Marquise Moissanite Halo Engagement Ring

by MemorialBoutique on Etsy

Fully Custom Engagement Rings

If you want something 100% one-of-a-kind and unique, consider commissioning a fully custom engagement ring.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (22)

Custom branch band engagement ring

from Ken & Dana Design

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (23)

Fully Custom Engagement Ring

from Suzie Saltzman Designs

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (24)

White diamond engagement ring

from James Allen

Your ring doesn’t have to be completely novel to be special. Customizing an engagement ring in a traditional style is still meaningful.

Shop here

– ADVERTISEMENT –

James Allen

James Allen gives you the power to create the perfect engagement ring, with the most prized diamonds and best selection of styles, combined with the latest technology.Design your perfect ring today!

Shop Now

Multiple Stone Engagement Rings

If you want an extra sparkly look for your ring, select a sparkler with a selection of stones instead of just one. Three-stone engagement rings are a popular choice because of their symbolic meanings. The trio of stones is meant to represent past, present, and future.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (26)

Pear-shaped Moissanite 3 Stone Engagement Ring

from Gardenring on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (27)

Custom 3 Stone Vertical Ring

from Bario Neal

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (28)

Three Stone Oval Sapphire Ring with Halo

from JewelleryBySpektor on Etsy

Three-stone rings with colored gemstones make for an even more special design.

Dainty Cluster Engagement Rings

When you don’t like the look of a big honkin’ rock, you go for something with a low profile like these clustered stone rings.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (29)

Cluster Diamond Rose Gold Ring

from roseandchoc on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (30)

Vintage British Cluster Ring

from LinnetJewellery on Etsy

Rainbow Stone Engagement Rings

Why not include the full rainbow of love in your engagement ring? Incorporate a rainbow studded band or consider a stone with all the colors, such as a mystic topaz or opal.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (31)

Mystic Topaz Engagement Ring

from Aquamarise on Etsy

This uniquely colored stone is surrounded by halo diamonds and a pave band for a polished look.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (32)

Rainbow Moonstone Engagement Ring

from Jewelluxe on Etsy

Listen to the Podcast:

Episode 04: Diamond Engagement Rings

Raw Stone Engagement Rings

Instead of selecting a perfectly shaped and cut gemstone, consider a raw stone. They are more uniquely shaped, as they are perfectly imperfect.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (33)

Rustic diamond slice ring

from AuroraDesigner on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (34)

Natural turquoise engagement ring

from thefoxandstone on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (35)

Raw opal engagement ring

from MoondropCreationsCA on Etsy

Dark Stone Engagement Rings

If your partner is more of the deep and classic type, perhaps you’d rather gift a dark stone like a black sapphire or onyx instead of a diamond.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (36)

Black Diamond Hexagon Ring

from ShopClementine on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (37)

Black Onyx Pear Engagement Ring

from HelloRing on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (38)

Oval Black Sapphire Engagement Ring

from FYMJewelryDesign on Etsy

Bezel Setting Engagement Rings

When looking for a way to make your ring choice more unique, consider choosing a unique setting such as the bezel.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (39)

Sunstone in bezel setting

from onegarnetgirl on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (40)

Bezel set sunstone ring

from RooRingCo on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (41)

Yellow gold bezel set engagement ring

from onegarnetgirl on Etsy

Vintage Engagement Rings

Instead of purchasing something new, shop for a vintage ring for something truly unique and special. Most likely your pre-owned bauble will also come with a dose of history!

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (42)

Art deco ring

from barzahav on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (44)

Moissanite Oval Vintage Engagement Ring

from NyFineJewelry on Etsy

Flower Setting Engagement Ring

If you want her ring to stand tall like a sunflower, choose an engagement ring with a halo of petal-like stones for a flowery look!

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (45)

Sunflower Black Diamond Engagement Ring

from ArmanteDesign on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (46)

Flower Morganite Engagement Ring

from NyFineJewelry on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (47)

Citrine Flower Engagement Ring

from godjewelry on Etsy

Starburst Engagement Ring Settings

When you want an out of this world engagement ring, there’s no better choice than a sparkly, starburst halo for a celestial vibe.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (48)

Moissanite cluster engagement ring

from Amandafinejewelry on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (49)

Round Simulated Diamond Starburst engagement ring

from LuxeryDesignsJewelry on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (50)

Morganite cluster engagement ring

from MinimalVS on Etsy

Celebrity-Inspired Engagement Rings

If you want to create a stunning engagement ring with a special meaning, then consider modeling it after a ring from a favorite story, movie or book!

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (51)

Emerald Ring with Sidestones

from jhollywooddesigns

Get a ring inspired by your favorite movie, like this one that looks like the Crazy Rich Asians ring.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (52)

Sapphire vintage style engagement ring

NYFineJewelry from Etsy

Crown Halo Engagement Bands

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (53)

Antique style opal engagement ring

by LoveRingsDesign

This ring comes with a with matching crown halo wedding band to complete the unique look.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (54)

Timeless emerald engagement ring with matching crown halo

by barzahav on Etsy

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (55)

Rosecut Green Sapphire engagement ring with crown

by AuroraDesigner on Etsy

Read More

Trending: Oval Engagement Rings

Unique Additions to make an Engagement Ring Extra Special

Looking for ways to add extra meaning to your engagement ring design for a truly unique piece of jewelry? Consider these creative options or add-ons!

Custom-Engraving

Adding an engraved message into your ring makes it extra meaningful. Include a special note, saying, or phrase inside your sweetie’s engagement ring if you want to make it extra unique.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (56)

Engraved engagement ring

from LimogésJewelry

If you want to add an extra dose of personalization to your ring, consider a hidden gemstone inside the band. You could make it your birthstone for a nod to the person who gave the ring!

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (57)

Engagement Ring with Signature Ruby

from Taylor & Hart

Infuse a hidden meaning

For those who want to add a hidden meaning into their engagement ring, may we suggest having a unique reasoning behind your choices? IE- select a stone that is your partner’s favorite color, or include three differently sized stones to represent past, present, and future, etc.

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (58)

Mint Sapphire Engagement Ring

from aardvarkjewellery on Etsy

Inspiration for Unique Engagement Rings

We hope this roundup of ideas and styles inspires you to customize some aspect of your engagement ring. If you’re looking for more engagement rings for women or men, be sure to check out our other articles on the subject!

  • Selling an Engagement Ring: Why, How, and Where
  • Men’s Wedding Rings and Engagement Rings: What You Need to Know
  • The Top Places to Find Eco-Friendly Engagement Rings
  • Ethical Custom Engagement Rings at Honest Prices
  • Trending: Oval Engagement Rings
  • Moonstone Engagement Rings: Magical Styles You’ll Swoon For

Did you find a ring that speaks to you? We hope this inspires you if you’re hoping to find a unique engagement ring for yourself or your partner!

📌 Pin This! 📌

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (59)
The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (60)

Get the Wedding Planning Quick Start Guide! 📋

Sign up for our wedding planning jumpstart series and we'll send you a FREE copy of our wedding planning timeline and checklist!

The Ultimate Guide to Unique Engagement Rings (2024)

FAQs

What is the golden rule for engagement rings? ›

The wedding band traditionally goes on the left-hand ring finger first, nearest the heart, with the engagement ring stacking on top. Again, this practice is not law, and the rings can be arranged in any way that is most comfortable and aesthetically pleasing to you, including wearing the rings on separate fingers.

What are the 4 C's of diamonds? ›

The 4Cs, are the globally accepted standard for assessing the quality of a diamond —color, clarity, cut and carat weight.

What is the most desired engagement ring? ›

"The round-cut diamond is consistently the most popular engagement ring shape," says Shannon Delany-Ron, CMO for online ring retailer James Allen, noting that its appearance is timeless, versatile, and provides plenty of sparkle.

How do you drop hints about what ring you want? ›

Below are 3 great ways to drop hints:
  1. Pin it. Brilliant Earth's Pinterest page is an excellent place for major engagement ring inspiration. ...
  2. Send a DM. While there are many ways to drop hints, Instagram makes the process more straightforward than ever. ...
  3. Click “Drop a Hint”

Is $10,000 too much for an engagement ring? ›

$10,000 is often cited as a substantial amount to allocate for an engagement ring, but it's essential to consider the average and median amounts spent by other couples to put things into perspective.

Is $10000 alot for an engagement ring? ›

Perhaps one that offers a bit more than just a diamond? If so, then $10,000 is an excellent budget to work with. You may have heard by now that $10,000 engagement rings are becoming more and more popular. The average of spending $5,000 on your engagement ring may soon be a thing of the past.

Which diamond cut gives the most sparkle? ›

Round Brilliant Cut

The round cut is the most brilliant or the most sparkling diamond cut. Fifty-eight facets (including the culet) are cut into brilliant round diamonds to allow light to pass through and reflect off each facet.

Do lab grown diamonds hold their value? ›

Lab grown diamonds certainly have value for their appearance and durability, and as we've mentioned they are exactly the same as natural diamonds in chemical make-up and hardness. From a monetary standpoint, however, your lab grown diamonds aren't going to hold very much value after they are taken out of the store.

How much should you spend on an engagement ring? ›

The ideal amount to spend can vary based on your circumstances and preferences. Customarily, spending about two months' salary on an engagement ring for women is often suggested.

What makes a ring look expensive? ›

Choosing colored stones over a single, larger diamond works effectively at making your engagement ring look expensive. Colored diamonds are not just beautiful and unique but also easily grab attention. Their bright color gives a beautiful look to your fingers as well as the ring and makes the ring look expensive.

What is the most classy diamond shape? ›

1. ROUND BRILLIANT DIAMOND. By far the most popular cut is the Round Brilliant, with it's fifty-seven perfectly aligned facets it's brilliance really does out-shine the others.

What is the least popular diamond shape? ›

The three least known diamond shapes
  • Ashley Bean. Pear.
  • Emerald.
  • Gray Box Studios. Emerald Halo Ring.
Mar 10, 2021

Should I tell my boyfriend what engagement ring I want? ›

Let them know what you like, so they can help guide your partner to the right choice. Most people still want the proposal to be a surprise, even if they've already discussed getting married. So let them do the shopping, but they'll feel a lot more confident with their choice if they know they're on the right track.

How do I find a unique ring? ›

7 Ways To Get Her A Unique Engagement Ring
  1. Adding a fancy color diamond.
  2. Fancy Blue Diamond Ring (Call For Pricing)
  3. Fancy Blue and Pink Diamond Ring (Call For Pricing)
  4. Choosing a gemstone as the center stone instead of a diamond.
  5. Having more than one metal type on the ring.
  6. Choosing a vintage ring.
  7. Adding a pop of color.

How to hint at engagement rings? ›

Browsing Jewelry Sites Together

While browsing through rings together, casually comment on the styles you find appealing. You can say things like, "I love the simplicity of solitaire settings; Keyzar solitaire rings are the best!" or "I've always admired rose gold bands; they have such a unique charm."

What is the 3 month rule for engagement rings? ›

Earlier, people spent their three-month salary on engagement rings as it was a popular notion. The cost of living back in the day was indeed much lower, and people could afford to spend 3 months' salary on a ring. However, times have changed and millennial couples don't generally follow this rule.

What is the 2 month rule for engagement rings? ›

You may have heard of the "two-month rule," which suggests you should spend two months' worth of your income on an engagement ring. While this may be what you have heard, the reality is that there is no set rule on how much money you should spend on an engagement ring!

What is the number one rule of engagement? ›

Golden Rule #1: Demonstrate and deliver value

Accordingly, in the very first moment of interaction with them, you must make a promise that you have something of value to offer them and deliver on that promise.

What is the diamond ring rule? ›

The three-month rule stems from a marketing campaign the De Beers diamond company ran in the 1930s that sold the idea that true love and commitment could only be shown if a man spent a month's salary on his wife's ring.

References

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Recommended Articles
Article information

Author: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Last Updated:

Views: 6426

Rating: 5 / 5 (70 voted)

Reviews: 93% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Dean Jakubowski Ret

Birthday: 1996-05-10

Address: Apt. 425 4346 Santiago Islands, Shariside, AK 38830-1874

Phone: +96313309894162

Job: Legacy Sales Designer

Hobby: Baseball, Wood carving, Candle making, Jigsaw puzzles, Lacemaking, Parkour, Drawing

Introduction: My name is Dean Jakubowski Ret, I am a enthusiastic, friendly, homely, handsome, zealous, brainy, elegant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.